Method
Our Sources
A sustainability score is only worth something if you can check the facts behind it. Every brand page links to the sources we used, so you can read the same reports and registries we read — and disagree with us if you want to.
What we cite
In rough order of preference, we cite:
- 1
Company sustainability and CSRD reporting
Annual sustainability reports, CSRD disclosures and dedicated sustainability or impact pages published by the brand itself. These are labelled as the company's own reporting on every brand page.
- 2
Certifier directories
B Lab (B Corp), Fair for Life, Fair Wear Foundation, Fair Labor Association, GOTS, Cradle to Cradle, FSC, EPA Safer Choice, Green Button and similar schemes — the certifying body's own directory where we can reach it.
- 3
Regulators and public registries
Official EU and national sources such as the EU Taxonomy and CSRD texts, and government-run labelling schemes.
- 4
NGO datasets and credible journalism
Established non-profits and newsrooms reporting on labour, pollution or supply-chain issues, where their reporting is specific enough to check.
Company reporting is disclosure, not verification
Most of what any company publishes about itself is self-reported. We use it — it is often the only public record of a supply chain — but we label it. On every brand page, sources that come from the company itself are marked as the company's own report. Sources from a certifier, a regulator or an NGO are marked as such, because an outside body checked them.
When a score rests mainly on the company's own numbers, we would rather say so plainly than dress it up as independent verification.
Access dates
Web pages change, move and disappear. Every source we list records the date we opened it and checked that the page really contained the claim we attribute to it. That date sits next to the link on the brand page.
If you open a link months later and the wording has changed, the access date tells you what we actually saw. We re-check sources when we review a rating.
When a claim cannot be sourced
If we cannot find a page that genuinely backs a claim, we do not list one. A plausible-looking link that does not say what we say it says is worse than no link at all.
Some brand pages therefore show a note saying sources are still being compiled, or carry fewer sources for a pillar than we would like. That is deliberate: the score reflects our analysis to date, and we would rather publish an honest gap than invent a citation.
Hummlan does not sell products and earns nothing from the brands we rate. That is why we can afford to show you the sources instead of asking you to trust us. Check a brand or read about the CSRD and EU Taxonomy frameworks behind the pillars.